There are people who come to therapy without being able to say what's wrong. There's a job, relationships are holding up, nothing bad has happened. Yet something has gone out. The phrase that recurs, almost always the same, is: “I no longer know why I do what I do”.
This form of suffering has a name: existential depression. It's not energy that's lacking — it's the reason to spend it.
What it is, and what it isn't
It must be said right away, for the sake of accuracy: existential depression is not a clinical diagnosis. It doesn't appear in diagnostic manuals as a category of its own. It's a description, born in philosophical circles and later entered into the language of psychotherapy, of a type of suffering that revolves around questions of meaning rather than symptoms.
Viktor Frankl called it existential vacuum: that sense of emptiness that appears when practical needs are satisfied and the question of why remains unanswered. Irvin Yalom described four issues that every human being sooner or later has to come to terms with: death, freedom and the weight of choice, fundamental loneliness, and the absence of a meaning given from the start.
Existential depression is what happens when one of these issues arises and no way is found to bear it.
How it manifests
- A sense of emptiness that coexists with an apparently full life
- The question “what's the point?” that creeps into activities that used to be done without thinking about them
- Apathy more than sadness: there's no acute suffering, you just feel disconnected
- The perception of playing a part, of functioning without really being there
- A sense of estrangement from others, even from those you love
- The acute and sudden awareness of mortality, which makes everything else seem out of proportion
Those who go through it often feel guilty for being in it: “I have no reason to complain.” And it's true that external reasons are lacking — which makes it harder to explain and lonelier to carry.
When it appears
It rarely arrives at the worst moments. Much more often it appears after.
After reaching a goal pursued for years, and discovering that nothing changes. At the end of a course of study, when the structure that held up the days falls away. During a life transition: the midpoint of life, children leaving home, retirement. After an illness or a loss, when the illusion of control cracks. Or simply during a period when, for the first time in a while, you stop.
It's the paradox that the film Souldescribes well: Joe's life happens while he's busy chasing his purpose.
The distinction that matters: is it a depressive episode?
This part is the most important in the whole article, because confusing the two has concrete consequences.
In the clinical depression the picture includes signals related to biological functioning: generalized and non-selective loss of pleasure, alterations in sleep and appetite, slowing down, fatigue that doesn't recover, difficulty concentrating, disproportionate guilt. It's a state that doesn't dissolve by thinking about it, and that requires a clinical evaluation.
In the existential suffering the ability to feel pleasure remains accessible in some areas, biological rhythms are generally preserved, and thinking is clear — all too clear. The question of meaning is active, not extinguished.
But the two things can coexist, and often do: a prolonged crisis of meaning can turn into a full-blown depressive episode. That's why the first thing to do isn't to decide on your own which category you're in, but to get evaluated. If you recognize yourself in the signals of the first group, the article on signs of depression not to ignore is the place to start from.
And if thoughts of harming yourself or no longer wanting to exist appear, don't wait: talk about it right away with your doctor, go to the emergency room or call the 112.
Why Gestalt works well on this ground
Gestalt psychotherapy is born within the humanistic-existential tradition, and this makes it particularly suited to a suffering that concerns meaning more than symptoms.
Because it starts from experience, not from explanations. To the question “why do I feel this way”, gestalt work responds by shifting it: what do you feel, right now, as you say it? Where do you feel it in your body? It's not a way to avoid the question, but to bring it back to where it can be faced. I wrote about it in the article on the phenomenological here and now.
Because it puts responsibility at the center. Not in the sense of blame, but in the sense that Sartre meant: you are not responsible for what you are, but you are responsible for what you do with what you are. Meaning is not found ready-made: it is built through choices.
Because it doesn't aim to bring you back to how you were before. According to the paradoxical theory of change, change happens when you stop fighting against what you are and start recognizing it. Those going through a crisis of meaning usually arrive asking to go back to functioning as before. The work often goes in the opposite direction: understanding what that crisis is trying to say.
Emptiness is not always a symptom
A clarification I want to make, because it risks being lost.
Not all existential suffering should be eliminated. Part of it signals something correct: that a life built on goals that aren't ours doesn't hold up, that something needs to be reconsidered. In those cases, the emptiness isn't the malfunction — it's the alarm that points it out to us.
Therapeutic work doesn't serve to silence that alarm, but to listen to it without being overwhelmed by it. It's different, and it makes a huge difference.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is existential depression a disease?
No, it's not a diagnostic category. It's a form of suffering related to questions of meaning. This doesn't make it any less real or any less heavy, and it doesn't exclude the possibility that it may accompany a depressive disorder, which instead must be clinically assessed.
What's the difference from an existential crisis?
They're the same area of experience, with different intensities. We speak of crisis when it's tied to a specific transition and tends to evolve; of existential depression when the state of emptiness stabilizes and begins to affect daily life.
Does it go away on its own?
Sometimes yes, when life brings a change that sets something in motion again. But if it lasts for months, if withdrawal from others increases, or if genuine depressive signs appear, waiting is not a strategy.
Is psychotherapy needed, or is talking to someone enough?
Talking about it always helps. Psychotherapy is needed when the question of meaning remains stuck, when you keep circling around the same thoughts without moving forward, or when the emptiness has begun to limit your choices.
Who suffers from it most?
It often appears in reflective people, demanding of themselves, accustomed to questioning themselves. It's not a sign of fragility: it's often the flip side of an ability to look at things all the way through.
A journey in Florence or online
If you recognize yourself in what you've read, you can contact me for an initial introductory session. I receive in my office in Florence, at Via Tommaso Campanella 5, in the Campo di Marte – Coverciano area, and online.
La perdita di senso è un tema che si lavora bene in psicoterapia della Gestalt: qui trovi il percorso per la depressione a Firenze.
Italian
English